smutsherpaLog in
Premium studios

Abby Winters vs Ersties

The two best-known real-women amateur sites. Abby Winters is the 20-year Australian original with a consent-first reputation; Ersties is the busier Berlin-based site with new clips most days.

76

Abby Winters

Higher score

Real amateur women, alone, together and with partners: a 20-year archive built on consent and natural looks.

Price
Pay per scene, about $1.50–$6.50 each; memberships also sold
Library
3,900+ updates

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • Genuine amateurs, natural and unretouched
  • Huge archive (3,900+ updates since 2002)
  • Known for its consent-first approach

Not so good

  • Softer and slower than mainstream porn
  • Updates have slowed (about 35 in the past year)
VisitFull review
74

Ersties

Female-led amateur erotica from Berlin: 3,800+ clips of real women, with new ones most days.

Price
—
Library
3,800+ clips

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • Real women, many first-timers
  • 3,800+ clips since 2009
  • Very active: about 170 new in the past year

Not so good

  • Mostly solo and girl-girl
  • Short clips (about 16 minutes)
  • Prices only shown at sign-up
VisitFull review

How they compare

Both feature real amateur women rather than pornstars, with natural looks and a relaxed, respectful feel.

Abby Winters has been running since 2002 and has more than 3,900 updates: solo, girl-girl and couples scenes, with a strong emphasis on consent. It still adds a few updates a month, and its scenes are longer, at about 28 minutes.

Ersties, based in Berlin, has more than 3,800 clips since 2009 and adds new ones most days, often with first-timers and interviews. Its clips are shorter, at about 16 minutes, and lean towards solo and girl-girl.