Premium studios

Erika Lust vs Abby Winters

Two ethical, consent-first sites. Erika Lust makes cinematic films directed by women and queer artists; Abby Winters has featured real amateur women since 2002, with 3,900+ updates and single scenes from about $1.50.

84

Erika Lust

Higher score

Barcelona-made ethical, cinematic porn: XConfessions, Lust Cinema and 700+ films.

Price
—
Library
—

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • Cinematic films made with performers as collaborators
  • XConfessions: viewers' fantasies turned into short films
  • Diverse directors, bodies and sexualities

Not so good

  • Pricier than mainstream studios
  • Less for fans of fast, gonzo-style scenes
76

Real amateur women, alone, together and with partners: a 20-year archive built on consent and natural looks.

Price
Pay per scene, about $1.50–$6.50 each; memberships also sold
Library
3,900+ updates

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • Genuine amateurs, natural and unretouched
  • Huge archive (3,900+ updates since 2002)
  • Known for its consent-first approach

Not so good

  • Softer and slower than mainstream porn
  • Updates have slowed (about 36 in the past year)

How they compare

Both put consent and real pleasure at the centre, but one is filmmaking and the other real amateurs.

Erika Lust has directed more than 200 films over 20 years, and the platform adds XConfessions, Lust Cinema and Live TV, with diverse casts, safe sex as standard and performers as collaborators. Prices are only shown at sign-up.

Abby Winters has featured real amateur women since 2002, solo, together and with partners, with natural bodies and no heavy make-up. It has more than 3,900 updates and adds a few a month, about 36 in the past year. Single scenes cost about $1.50 to $6.50 each, and memberships are also sold.

Erika Lust vs Abby Winters (2026): which is better? · SmutSherpa