smutsherpaLog in
Premium studios

Milfy vs Naughty America

Milfy wins on polish; Naughty America on volume and price. Milfy is Vixen's cinematic MILF studio with a new scene every week; Naughty America has 12,000+ 4K videos across 47 sites, with a strong MILF side, for $119.40 a year.

78

Milfy

Vixen Media Group's MILF studio: polished scenes with mature performers, new every week.

Price
—
Trial
—

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • Vixen-level production
  • A new scene every Wednesday
  • 180+ scenes, around 36 minutes each

Not so good

  • Premium pricing
  • Younger library than most MILF sites
VisitFull review
80

Naughty America

Higher score

Long-running US studio known for its scenario-based scenes.

Price
$29.95/mo (sale; usually $39.95); $119.40/year; Gold Pass with 11 premium sites $239.40/year
Trial
$1.95 for 3 days (limited to select videos)

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • 12,000+ exclusive 4K videos across 47 sites
  • New scenes daily
  • 4K, VR and unlimited downloads included
  • $119.40 a year

Not so good

  • Formulaic scenarios
  • The $1.95 trial is limited to select videos
VisitFull review

How they compare

Milfy brings Vixen Media Group's cinematic production to MILF porn: about 180 polished, story-led scenes of 32 to 39 minutes, with a new one every Wednesday.

Naughty America is a long-running US studio built on scenario-based scenes (the neighbour, the teacher, the office) with a strong MILF side: more than 12,000 exclusive 4K videos across 47 sites, new scenes daily, and VR and downloads included. It's $29.95 a month on sale (usually $39.95) or $119.40 a year.

Milfy is the most polished MILF site; Naughty America gives you far more MILF scenes, and much else, for the money.