smutsherpaLog in
Premium studios

MYLF vs Naughty America

Both are known for MILF scenes: MYLF is a dedicated 30-series MILF network; Naughty America mixes MILF scenarios with other sub-sites and VR.

82

MYLF

Higher score

Paper Street Media's MILF network: 30 series of mature performers, from anal and creampies to JOI and femdom.

Price
$32.99/mo or $149/year to stream; $365/year for every Paper Street network; $1 one-day trial
Deal
Halloween offer: first month $9.95 (renews at $32.99/mo); first year $99.95 (renews at $149)
Trial
$1 for 1 day (limited; renews at $39.99)

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • 30 MILF series under one login
  • Well-known performers and frequent debuts
  • 4K streaming, ad-free
  • $149 a year is a big saving

Not so good

  • Heavy on roleplay scenarios
  • Separate from the regular TeamSkeet membership
  • Streaming only
VisitFull review
80

Naughty America

Long-running US studio known for its scenario-based scenes.

Price
$29.95/mo (sale; usually $39.95); $119.40/year; Gold Pass with 11 premium sites $239.40/year
Deal
—
Trial
$1.95 for 3 days (limited to select videos)

Prices checked October 2026

Good

  • 12,000+ exclusive 4K videos across 47 sites
  • New scenes daily
  • 4K, VR and unlimited downloads included
  • $119.40 a year

Not so good

  • Formulaic scenarios
  • The $1.95 trial is limited to select videos
VisitFull review

How they compare

MYLF and Naughty America are two of the first names for MILF scenes, but they're built differently. MYLF, from Paper Street Media, is MILF-only: 30 series of mature performers (AnalMom, MomDrips, MilfBody, Tiger Moms, Oye Mami and more), streaming in up to 4K. Naughty America is a long-running US studio whose sub-sites include classic MILF set-ups such as My Friend's Hot Mom and Seduced by a Cougar alongside office, neighbour and VR scenes.

MYLF is $32.99 a month or $149 a year to stream, with a $1 one-day trial. Naughty America was $29.95 a month on sale (usually $39.95) or $119.40 a year, with a limited $1.95 three-day trial. Prices are at the time of writing.